Glycolic Acid for Melanin-Rich Skin: Safe Use & PIH Prevention

Most published research on glycolic acid has been conducted predominantly on lighter skin tones. Fitzpatrick skin types IV through VI - encompassing a wide range of South Asian, East Asian, Middle Eastern, Hispanic/Latino, and Black skin tones - have been systematically underrepresented in dermatological research [1]. This matters because melanin-rich skin responds differently to chemical exfoliation, and recommendations developed on lighter skin do not always translate safely. The good news: glycolic acid can be highly effective for darker skin tones when used correctly. The critical caveat: "correctly" means a more conservative approach than what most product labels and general guides suggest.

Understanding Melanin-Rich Skin

The Fitzpatrick scale classifies skin into six phototypes based on how skin responds to UV radiation. Types IV through VI represent a spectrum of melanin-rich skin:

• Type IV: Moderate brown skin that tans easily, rarely burns. Common in Mediterranean, Middle Eastern, and some Asian and Latino populations.
• Type V: Dark brown skin that tans very easily, very rarely burns. Common in South Asian, Middle Eastern, Latino, and some African populations.
• Type VI: Deeply pigmented dark brown to black skin that never burns. Common in many African, African-American, and Aboriginal Australian populations.

These classifications are relevant to glycolic acid use because of a fundamental biological difference: melanocyte reactivity. Melanocytes are the cells that produce melanin, the pigment that gives skin its color. In Fitzpatrick IV-VI skin, melanocytes are not more numerous than in lighter skin - but they are more active and more reactive to stimuli [2]. When the skin experiences inflammation, trauma, or irritation of any kind, melanocytes in darker skin respond by producing excess melanin. This response is a protective mechanism, but it results in dark marks and patches that can persist for months or years.

This heightened reactivity is the single most important factor governing how people with melanin-rich skin should approach glycolic acid.

The Melanin Production Response

When glycolic acid is applied to skin, it disrupts desmosomes in the stratum corneum - the protein bonds holding dead cells together - which triggers controlled exfoliation [3]. This process involves a mild inflammatory cascade. In lighter skin, this inflammation resolves without visible pigmentation changes. In melanin-rich skin, even mild inflammation can stimulate melanocytes to overproduce melanin, depositing it in the epidermis (or worse, in the dermis where it is much harder to treat).

The irony is stark: many people with darker skin tones seek glycolic acid specifically to treat hyperpigmentation, uneven tone, or dark spots. But if the acid causes even low-level irritation, it can create new hyperpigmentation - worsening the exact condition the person was trying to improve.

Clinical Evidence in Darker Skin Tones

Despite the underrepresentation in research, several key studies have specifically examined glycolic acid in darker-skinned populations.

Glycolic Acid Peels for PIH

Burns et al. (1997) conducted a comparative study of serial glycolic acid peels (concentrations up to 68%) in 19 Black patients (Fitzpatrick V-VI) with post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation. The study found that glycolic acid peels provided additional clinical improvement in PIH beyond what a topical regimen of hydroquinone and tretinoin achieved alone. Side effects were minimal when the protocol included careful titration and appropriate contact times [4]. This was an early and important demonstration that glycolic acid peels can be both safe and effective in deeply pigmented skin - but only under professional supervision with cautious protocols.

Glycolic Acid Peels in South Asian Skin

Sarkar et al. (2002) studied the combination of glycolic acid peels with a topical regimen (modified Kligman formula) for melasma in dark-skinned patients (Fitzpatrick IV-V). Patients receiving glycolic acid peels (20-35%, every three weeks for six sessions) plus topical therapy showed greater improvement in melasma severity than those using topical therapy alone [5]. A subsequent 2012 review by Sarkar et al. confirmed that glycolic acid peels are among the safest chemical peel options for dark-skinned patients when properly administered, with a lower risk of adverse pigmentary outcomes compared to salicylic acid or trichloroacetic acid peels [6].

Grimes on Chemical Peels in Skin of Color

Grimes (1999) published one of the most cited reviews on chemical peels in skin of color, concluding that superficial glycolic acid peels (20-50%) are effective for treating acne, PIH, pseudofolliculitis barbae, and melasma in Fitzpatrick IV-VI skin. The review emphasized that the key to safe outcomes is a conservative approach: lower starting concentrations, shorter initial contact times, gradual escalation, and immediate neutralization at first sign of excessive erythema or discomfort [7].

Kaidbey and Kligman: The Irritation Threshold

Foundational work by Kaidbey and Kligman (1979) on racial differences in skin irritation response demonstrated that Black skin shows a different inflammatory pattern compared to White skin when exposed to the same irritants. The stratum corneum in darker skin tends to be more compact with more cell layers, which can provide some initial barrier protection - but once that barrier is breached, the subsequent inflammatory response triggers more pronounced pigmentary consequences [8].

Post-Inflammatory Hyperpigmentation: The Primary Concern

PIH is not a side effect unique to glycolic acid - it can result from any source of skin inflammation, including acne, eczema, cuts, burns, laser treatments, or aggressive skincare. But glycolic acid occupies a paradoxical position: it is both a treatment for PIH and a potential cause of it.

How Glycolic Acid Treats PIH

Glycolic acid addresses existing hyperpigmentation through two mechanisms:

1. Accelerated exfoliation: By increasing the turnover rate of epidermal cells, glycolic acid helps shed pigment-laden keratinocytes faster. Dark marks that might take 6-12 months to fade on their own can be visibly reduced in 2-3 months with consistent glycolic acid use [6].
2. Tyrosinase inhibition: Usuki et al. (2003) demonstrated that glycolic acid directly inhibits tyrosinase - the enzyme responsible for melanin synthesis - in melanoma cells [9]. This means glycolic acid does not just remove existing pigment faster; it also slows the production of new melanin.

How Glycolic Acid Causes PIH

When glycolic acid is used at too high a concentration, too frequently, or on skin that is not yet tolerant, the resulting irritation triggers an inflammatory cascade. In melanin-rich skin, this inflammation stimulates melanocytes to produce excess melanin as a protective response. The result: new dark marks appear, often in the same areas where the acid was applied.

The risk factors for glycolic acid-induced PIH include:

• Concentration too high for the individual's tolerance level - jumping straight to 10% or higher without building tolerance
• Too-frequent application - daily use before the skin has adapted
• Inadequate sun protection - UV exposure amplifies melanocyte activity after acid exfoliation
• Combining multiple irritating actives - layering glycolic acid with retinoids, vitamin C at low pH, or benzoyl peroxide without sufficient spacing
• Ignoring early warning signs - persistent redness, stinging that lasts more than 5 minutes, or visible darkening at the application site

Safe Use Guidelines for Fitzpatrick IV-VI Skin

The core principle is simple: start lower and go slower than general recommendations suggest. General glycolic acid guides often recommend starting at 7-10% for most skin types. For melanin-rich skin, this starting point is too aggressive.

The Conservative Protocol

1. Patch test first. Apply the product to a small area behind the ear or on the inner forearm. Wait 48-72 hours. Check not just for redness and irritation, but specifically for any darkening of the test area.

2. Start at 5% or lower. A 5% glycolic acid toner or serum applied 1-2 times per week is the safest entry point. If you have never used any chemical exfoliant before, consider starting with a glycolic acid cleanser (2-4%) - the short contact time provides an even gentler introduction.

3. Increase frequency before concentration. Move from 1-2 times per week to 3 times per week, then to every other day, then to daily - all at the same concentration. Only after you have used 5% daily for at least 6 weeks with zero irritation should you consider moving to a higher concentration.

4. Use the buffering technique when starting out. Apply your moisturizer first, let it absorb for 5 minutes, then apply the glycolic acid on top. This creates a physical buffer that reduces the effective acid delivery and minimizes irritation risk during the tolerance-building phase.

5. Never skip sunscreen. SPF 50+ broad-spectrum sunscreen, every single day, applied to all treated areas. This is non-negotiable. UV exposure after glycolic acid use is the fastest route to new PIH in melanin-rich skin.

6. Do not exceed 10% without professional guidance. For unsupervised home use, 10% is the maximum recommended concentration for Fitzpatrick IV-VI skin. Higher concentrations (20%+) should only be used under the supervision of a dermatologist experienced with skin of color.

7. Allow longer intervals between concentration increases. While general guides suggest 4-week intervals, melanin-rich skin benefits from 6-8 weeks between any increase in concentration or frequency.

Recommended Concentrations by Experience Level

This progression is significantly slower than what general guides recommend. That is intentional. The cost of moving too fast in melanin-rich skin - months of PIH that is harder to treat than whatever you were trying to fix - far outweighs the cost of spending a few extra weeks at each concentration level.

The Mandelic Acid Alternative

If glycolic acid proves too irritating even at low concentrations, mandelic acid deserves serious consideration - especially for melanin-rich skin.

Why Mandelic Acid Is Gentler

Mandelic acid is an alpha hydroxy acid derived from bitter almonds with a molecular weight of 152.15 Da - exactly twice that of glycolic acid (76.05 Da) [3]. This larger molecular size means mandelic acid penetrates the stratum corneum more slowly and less deeply, producing less irritation at equivalent concentrations.

But molecular weight is not the only advantage. Mandelic acid is partially lipophilic (oil-soluble), which gives it properties that are particularly relevant for melanin-rich skin:

• Slower, more uniform penetration - less risk of the uneven acid delivery that causes localized irritation spots
• Antibacterial properties - effective against Cutibacterium acnes, making it useful for acne-prone darker skin that is also PIH-prone
• Melanin regulation - Hakozaki et al. (2002) demonstrated that mandelic acid, like glycolic acid, affects melanin production, but with a gentler approach that reduces the PIH risk [10]

When to Choose Mandelic Over Glycolic

Consider mandelic acid as your primary AHA if:

• Glycolic acid at 5% causes irritation even with buffering and 1x/week application
• You have a history of PIH from other skincare products or treatments
• You want to begin chemical exfoliation with the lowest possible risk
• Your primary concern is acne-related PIH (mandelic acid's antibacterial properties address both the acne and the resulting dark marks)

You can always transition to glycolic acid later once your skin has built tolerance to chemical exfoliation through mandelic acid use. See our complete AHA comparison for a detailed breakdown of how mandelic acid compares to glycolic acid and other AHAs.

Building a Routine for Melanin-Rich Skin

A complete routine for melanin-rich skin using glycolic acid should prioritize barrier protection and PIH prevention at every step.

Evening Routine (Glycolic Acid Nights - 2-3x/week to start)

1. Gentle cleanser - Fragrance-free, non-foaming or low-foam. Harsh cleansers strip the barrier before you even apply the acid, increasing irritation risk.
2. Glycolic acid (5%(Low concentration) to start) - Apply to dry skin. If you are in the first month, use the buffering technique (moisturizer first, acid on top). Wait 1-2 minutes to let the product absorb.
3. Niacinamide serum (4-5%) - Niacinamide is a critical addition for melanin-rich skin. It inhibits melanosome transfer from melanocytes to keratinocytes, directly reducing the pigment deposition that causes PIH [10]. It also strengthens the skin barrier, reducing the chance that glycolic acid will cause irritation in the first place. Apply after the glycolic acid has absorbed.
4. Moisturizer - Ceramide-based, fragrance-free. Restores and reinforces the skin barrier after acid exfoliation.

Evening Routine (Non-Acid Nights)

1. Gentle cleanser
2. Niacinamide serum - Use every evening, not just on glycolic acid nights
3. Moisturizer

Morning Routine (Every Day)

1. Gentle cleanser (or rinse with water)
2. Antioxidant serum - Vitamin C (L-ascorbic acid 10-15%) provides additional protection against UV-induced melanin production. Optional but beneficial.
3. Moisturizer - Lightweight, non-comedogenic
4. Sunscreen SPF 50+ - Broad-spectrum. Apply generously. Reapply every 2 hours if outdoors. This is the single most important step for preventing PIH in melanin-rich skin.

Products and Ingredients to Avoid While Using Glycolic Acid

Do not combine glycolic acid with other potentially irritating actives on the same evening:

• Retinoids (tretinoin, retinol) - alternate evenings with glycolic acid, never layer them
• Benzoyl peroxide - use in the morning or on non-acid evenings
• Other AHAs or BHAs - do not stack multiple exfoliants
• Vitamin C at low pH - can be used in the morning, but not layered with glycolic acid in the evening
• Physical scrubs - mechanical exfoliation combined with chemical exfoliation is a fast route to irritation and PIH

For detailed ingredient interaction guidance, see our side effects and safety guide.

When to See a Dermatologist

Professional guidance is particularly important for melanin-rich skin. Seek a dermatologist - ideally one experienced with skin of color - in these situations:

• Before starting glycolic acid if you have active PIH, melasma, or a history of adverse reactions to skincare products
• If you want concentrations above 10% - professional peels at 20-50% can be highly effective for PIH, melasma, and acne in darker skin, but they require careful monitoring and adjustment based on real-time skin response [7]
• If you develop new PIH from glycolic acid use - a dermatologist can assess whether the hyperpigmentation is epidermal (treatable, responds to topicals) or dermal (much more persistent, may require different interventions)
• If you have melasma - this condition is notoriously difficult to treat and is worsened by inflammation. Glycolic acid can be part of a melasma treatment plan, but self-treating melasma with acids carries significant PIH risk [5]
• If over-the-counter products have not improved your hyperpigmentation after 3 months of consistent use - professional-strength treatments may be needed

Key Takeaways

Glycolic acid is a valuable ingredient for melanin-rich skin. It can effectively treat hyperpigmentation, improve skin texture, address acne, and promote an even, radiant complexion. The clinical evidence - from Burns, Sarkar, Grimes, and others - supports its safety and efficacy in Fitzpatrick IV-VI skin when conservative protocols are followed.

The difference between success and setback with glycolic acid in darker skin tones comes down to discipline: starting at genuinely low concentrations, advancing slowly, protecting the skin from UV exposure every single day, and stopping at the first sign of irritation rather than pushing through it. The melanocyte reactivity that defines melanin-rich skin is not a barrier to using glycolic acid - it is simply a variable that requires a more thoughtful approach.

For a broader view of how glycolic acid works across all skin types, see our skin type guide. For help choosing the right concentration regardless of skin tone, see our concentration guide. And if you want to compare glycolic acid to gentler alternatives like lactic acid, see our glycolic vs. lactic acid comparison.

References

1. 1. Taylor SC (2002). Dermatology and the demographics of skin color. J Am Acad Dermatolreview
2. 2. Wesley NO, Maibach HI (2003). Racial differences in skin properties: melanocyte activity, stratum corneum structure, and barrier function. Am J Clin Dermatolreview
3. 3. Fartasch M, Teal J, Menon GK (1997). Mode of action of glycolic acid on human stratum corneum: ultrastructural and functional evaluation of the epidermal barrier. Arch Dermatol Resin vitro study
4. 4. Burns RL, Prevost-Blank PL, Lawry MA, et al. (1997). Glycolic acid peels for postinflammatory hyperpigmentation in black patients. A comparative study. Dermatol Surgcomparative study
5. 5. Sarkar R, Kaur C, Bhalla M, Kanwar AJ (2002). The combination of glycolic acid peels with a topical regimen in the treatment of melasma in dark-skinned patients: a comparative study. Dermatol Surgcomparative study
6. 6. Sarkar R, Bansal S, Garg VK (2012). Chemical peels for melasma in dark-skinned patients. J Cutan Aesthet Surgreview
7. 7. Grimes PE (1999). The use of chemical peeling agents in the treatment of skin of color. Dermatol Therreview
8. 8. Kaidbey KH, Kligman AM (1979). The role of race in skin irritation response. Arch Dermatolclinical study
9. 9. Usuki A, Ohashi A, Sato H, et al. (2003). The inhibitory effect of glycolic acid and lactic acid on melanin synthesis in melanoma cells. Exp Dermatolin vitro study
10. 10. Hakozaki T, Minwalla L, Zhuang J, et al. (2002). Niacinamide decreases post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation through suppression of melanosome transfer. Br J Dermatolin vitro/clinical study

Related Articles

usage12 min min read

Glycolic Acid for Different Skin Types

Tailored advice for oily, dry, sensitive, combination, acne-prone, and mature skin.

usage10 min min read

Choosing the Right Concentration

From 5% daily toners to 70% professional peels - find the right strength.

science11 min min read

Side Effects & Safety

Complete guide to glycolic acid side effects and how to avoid them.

comparisons9 min min read

Glycolic Acid vs Lactic Acid

Two AHAs compared - lactic acid may be a gentler alternative for sensitive darker skin.

comparisons12 min min read

Glycolic Acid vs Other AHAs

Full comparison including mandelic acid - a key alternative for melanin-rich skin.

usage3 min min read

Free Acid Calculator

Calculate the actual active acid in any product by concentration and pH.